Bhutta and Huq (1999) designed an integrated matrix, with two dimensions; "to what is compared" and "what the comparison is being made against." Bhutta and Huq suggest every cell in the matrix be carefully evaluated in accordance with relativity.
1. To What Is Compared
There are three kinds of benchmarks implemented in comparative analysis:
(1) Performance Benchmarking -
According to Bhutta & Huq"s definition, is to compare process of competitors with their own, in order to evaluate their own performance.
(2) Process Benchmarking -
Relates to every methods and process capable of improving business process.
(3) Strategic Benchmarking -
When companies need to change their strategy, Strategic Benchmarking can be implemented to find out how their competitors" strategies are formed. Thus improving their own plans and design.
2. What the comparison is being made against.
The four ways of comparison are:
(1) Internal Benchmarking -
Implemented when comparing performance of different departments or sections within the company in order to find the best process. For instance, multinational enterprises can learn through implementing the same process in different subsidies. Such information not only is very easy to acquire, but also greatly facilitates information exchange within the organization.
(2) Competitive Benchmarking -
Implemented on competitors who provide similar goods and services. Companies, through comparing and analyzing, are able to find out the best practices of competitors in services and processes. Making it possible to close the gap between them. Due to the similarity with competitors, the best practices found are easy to apply on companies themselves.
(3) Functional Benchmarking -
Applied upon non-competitors within the sector or technologically related. Through comparison on process and function, companies are able to learn from these outstanding examples.
(4) Generic Benchmarking -
Applied to other industries. Companies learn different processes from different sectors, stimulating new ideas and methods and enabling companies to break through traditional thinking.
The two dimensions mentioned above can be integrated into the fallowing 3*4 matrix:
|